AZ group making waves on HOA issues

By Deborah Goonan, Independent American Communities


Arizona Senator David Farnsworth (R) has been meeting with a group of concerned citizens to discuss regulation of Association Governed Housing (Homeowners’, Condominium, and Cooperative Associations) in the state. The group includes several professionals seeking to rein what they call excessive power of HOAs, among them Attorney Steve Cheifetz (Iannitelli & Marcolinni) and Scottsdale resident and Realtor Jill Schweitzer.

Two of the dozen or so proposals being discussed:

  • Restoration of Homestead Protection of up to $150,000 in home equity in the event of HOA foreclosure or financial judgment
  • Legal requirement for Community Association Management companies to disclose gifts or monetary compensation from vendors it refers to HOA Boards

In the past, the HOA “mastermind” group has struggled to find consensus on legislative reform measures. Farnsworth says this is because special interest groups tend to infiltrate the meetings, advocating for their own political agendas.

One obstacle to change is resistance from those who lead what they claim are trouble-free HOAs.

For example, HOA Board member and Vice Mayor of Paradise Valley, David Sherf, does not seem to think legislative change is necessary. He claims his Association has experienced little conflict and operates without difficulty.

Sherf is quoted in the following article.

Arizona citizens band together to address legislative powers of HOAs 

By Terence Thornton


Vice Mayor Sherf says in his four years serving on his HOA board he hasn’t seen much in the way of dissent from the local homeowners.

“A validation of this statement is that our annual meeting only attracts about seven to 10 residents at most and our four to five meetings each year typically attract less people than that,” he said. “As a board, we think we must be doing the right things as we have such few people attend the meetings.”

Read more here:

In other words, according to Sherf, non-participation of residents in their HOA meetings is a sign of success. The insinuation is that, if members were to attend, it would only be to complain or present their problems to the HOA Board.

Unfortunately, this stance is typical of politicians and corporate business leaders such as Sherf, a CPA and former Senior VP of Hilton Hotels Corporation, who has led a highly successful career in hotel development and asset management.

But let’s face it. The vast majority of HOAs do not have residents with David Sherf’s depth and breadth of financial and business management experience. And only a fortunate few have a political “in” with their municipality.

The fact is, a great many HOA Boards are led by members with no financial or management experience – the kind who might not even manage their personal finances effectively. In reality, many thousands of HOAs are handing over control of  5- or 6-figure annual budgets to volunteers who don’t even know how to balance their checkbooks.

Other HOAs may remain under the control of a developer or investor group for many years while a community is still under construction. Quite often, developer interests do not coincide with consumer (homeowner) interests.

And regardless of the quality of leadership, owners and residents of Association Governed Housing are entitled to equal protection of their rights, including the right to transparent and democratic governance. Those are two qualities many residents find lacking in their HOAs.

These are all very good reasons to rein in the power of HOA Boards and to regulate community association developers and management companies – regardless of the fact that some prominent HOAs appear to function as intended.

For more information, click here:

Grassroots group meets monthly to discuss HOA issues


8 Replies to “AZ group making waves on HOA issues”

  1. David Sheff’s comment that a low turnout for an Annual General Meeting indicates that owners are generally happy with the operations of their community is similar to what I have experienced as well. I, along with the Board, would prefer to have more in attendance. I can assure all, that if a large special assessment notice went out just before the AGM package, there would be many more in attendance.

    One way various Boards and I increased attendance was to set the date of the Annual General Meeting in stone, the same day of the year, year after year, i.e., the second Tuesday night of May. This allowed me, as manager, to continually remind owners all year long that there is no excuse to miss the meeting – it helped.


    1. Owners in my community have been trained all right, that attending meetings is a waste of our time. Board “representatives” and the property manager are disingenuous. Tainted elections run by them, pass. There are plenty of reasons to miss the annual meeting.


  2. Hello, Theresa – Why don’t you and fellow owners remove those Board member that are not looking after the interest of the entire community and replace with volunteers that do genuinely care?


    1. Tom, thanks for your insight and suggestion. Do you know what tainted means? I exposed election cheating. Let’s discuss further when you aren’t on the payroll and have unqualified busybodies misspending about a half million dollars annually.


  3. Yes, I know what tainted means and I also know how hard it is to remove Board Members, but I can not accept that if it is so bad then why you and your fellow owners don’t buckle down and get the necessary support for replacing the Board with volunteers with similar values as you. Would you have volunteers willing to step up the plate?


    1. Nearly all owners are apathetic and ignorant about HOA matters. The board refuses to receive owner input or have an impartial third party conduct elections. The bad board and property manager control all touchpoints of election processes. A willing volunteer replacement is not enough. This is a big responsibility requiring education, experience, and business and people management skills amongst others. Communities—especially smaller ones like mine—cannot supply enough qualified volunteers to fill rotating board seats. HOAs are conceptually flawed.


  4. Extremely sad!!! I think it is great that you are part of the Senator Farnswoth’s workgroup. Unfortunately, with your particular small HOA which is misspending a half a million dollars annually, I don’t believe you have the luxury of waiting for another level of government to solve your current issues.

    HOAs are conceptually flawed – absolutely


Public Comment policy: all comments subject to review. Please keep comments respectful. To send a private message, please use the feedback form instead.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.